Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alex Watson's avatar

There's a lot of advice in here that I agree with.

Networking matters.

Libraries and university career services are underused.

AI can be helpful when used carefully.

But there are a couple of points I'd challenge.

The first is the recommendation to use a "simple ATS-friendly resume template" because that's supposedly what candidates need. The ATS-friendly resume narrative has become so common that people rarely question it anymore.

In reality, most ATS platforms are databases. They store, organise, search, and track applicants. They are not sitting there rejecting candidates because they used the wrong template.

After 12 years recruiting across the US, UK, and Europe, I've never used an ATS that automatically rejected someone because their resume wasn't "ATS-friendly."

I've received resumes with tables, columns, graphics, logos, colours, and every formatting choice imaginable.

I've even had people accidentally upload tax returns and wedding invitations instead of resumes.

The system still accepted the document.

The recruiter could still review it.

The hiring decision was still made by a human.

A clean template is a good idea because it improves readability, not because it helps you beat an ATS.

I'd also push back slightly on the claim that applying early is important because otherwise your application may never get seen if it's buried under hundreds of others.

Being early can help.

But it's often overstated.

I've filled roles where candidates applied within hours and I've filled roles where candidates applied weeks later. What matters far more is relevance.

Recruiters don't usually review applications in strict chronological order. Many search, filter, sort, and revisit applications throughout the hiring process.

A highly relevant candidate applying on day 10 often beats a weak candidate who applied on day 1.

Overall, the strongest message in the article isn't about ATS templates or being first.

It's about using free resources, building relationships, improving your positioning, and making your search more strategic.

Those things genuinely move the needle.

ATS optimisation and application timing tend to get far more attention than they deserve.

No posts

Ready for more?